Let me start by saying it’s been a while since I’ve felt passionate enough about something like this to write an entire blog post, but here we are. I’m not here to argue with people who are transphobic, those who vehemently insist posts like the ones I’m going to mention are not transphobic, or trolls of any type. I’m here for the lurkers – the ones who are on the fence or still learning about what being an ally is or trying to decide if they are one.
It all started with a picture of a basketball that had “I identify as a pumpkin” written on it in sharpie that was placed in the middle of a holiday pumpkin display. The caption was “Welcome to Halloween in 2019.”
It took me just about all day to get to the root of why it bothered me and how to articulate those ideas. Put simply, posts like those, which make their rounds on social media all the time, are transphobic. Whether they’re meant to be that way or not, that’s what they are.
Here are the common arguments against my perspective and my rebuttals to them. You’re welcome.
- If everyone is “too politically correct,” humor will no longer exist.
Step one: throw the term politically correct in the trash. It’s a misused and unclear term for what is usually just empathy.
Step two: Don’t be a lazy comedian. This is far from an original idea – I’ve seen tons of comedians explain why jokes against minorities are so overrated. There’s lots more out there if you try a little bit harder and get educated on comedy theory. (I’ll give you a hint – loss of control i.e. those videos of people falling, comedy about animals, and other “relatable” content will almost always get a chuckle from me.)
- “My trans [insert other minorities] friend thinks it’s funny.”
STOP there. This is another form of “I have a black friend,” but worse. One person cannot say for a fact that their opinion reflects that of their entire community. Your one friend of this community cannot say that another person in that community, especially one who is not out (in the case of specific gender and sexuality communities) wouldn’t be hurt by this.
- “We need to laugh at ourselves.”
Are you a member of the community that this joke is about? If it’s not at your expense, you really don’t have a right to say that.
- iT’s JuSt A jOkE
Maybe it is to you. Maybe you meant no harm in sharing it. But let me point this out: the wording, specifically the term “identify” is loaded. In this context and in the context of our culture and political climate at this time, images such as these were intended for the audience of people who don’t believe you can look like one thing and identify as something else. Those people are inherently anti-trans. This could’ve easily gone a different direction if the pumpkin said, “don’t tell them I’m not a pumpkin” or “this is my Halloween costume” or something along those lines that depicts it as an undercover basketball or a basketball dressed up for Halloween. The word identify is a red flag here.
My other issues with posts like these:
A: It’s using inanimate objects to symbolize real people and their feelings and their lives. You can’t get much more objectifying than that – thanks patriarchy and new application for the male gaze.
B: Anything with any variation of “crying,” “snowflake,” or other name-calling and the message of “you’re being too emotional” is usually gas lighting (definition – to manipulate (someone) by psychological means into questioning their own sanity.) This response can earn you a swift block from me.
C: Do we not still teach children “it’s what’s on the inside that counts?” Allies don’t care what you look like – it’s not relevant to our respect for people.
D: The phrase “Welcome to Halloween in 2019” insinuates that being a different gender or sexuality is a trend or something new. It’s making light of something that a lot of people have suffered over for years in silence.
E: This picture is essentially saying, “you’re a basketball and you’ll never be a pumpkin no matter how hard you try.” In this case, those items seem to be placeholders for woman and man. So, if I have any trans friends out there reading, I just want to say, you’re a fucking pumpkin and don’t let anyone tell you any different.
I’ll end this by quoting myself, “Yeah, I guess I’m serious as a heart attack when it comes to posts that I feel like further degrade minorities that already have a rough go of it.”




